Earlier this week I got stuck in some major traffic as I drove past a middle school. I had never, ever, ever seen so many cars (well, SUVs and minivans) before waiting in line to drop off kids at school before. I was amazed at how horribly inefficient that was.
And then I saw this piece today:
In Exurbs, Life Framed by Hours Spent in the Car – New York Times
The result is that the modern exurb has more daytime residents than the suburbs did a generation ago, urban experts say. More people frequent a different mix of shops, restaurants and recreational facilities. And that has created more traffic throughout the day, the morning rush hours giving way to gridlock caused by shoppers, school drop-offs and lunch throngs.
As a resident since 1993, Mr. Kinnunen qualifies as an old-timer in Frisco. And although most newer residents say they have found it easy to make friends, older residents note a subtle change in the pattern of life as subdivisions spread and people spend more time in the car.
“We don’t really see our neighbors so much anymore,” Mr. Kinnunen said. “We all drive into our back alleys and into our garage, and that’s that.”
[snip]
People are too jealous of their time, because they have to be.”
Jay Crutcher, a lawyer who commutes to downtown Dallas from Frisco, said any trip of under an hour constituted a good day.
We love the car because it provides us freedom… like in the ads on TV. But all that happens is that we get stuck in traffic. If you saw the parking lot for my high school, you’d probably be shocked at how tiny it is – because there was a great school bus system that everyone took.
It’s no suprise that we don’t understand trade-offs, because often times they’re too abstract and they require forward thinking – just look at retirement saving rates!) We don’t want mass transit because it’s not efficient and you don’t have freedom, and its expensive to support through taxes. It’s “cheaper” and you get “more freedom” to if we built more roads and everyone had their own cars.
But then we get stuck in traffic, fight for parking spots, wonder why our roads are so awful, clamor for more roads (even as we can’t afford to maintain the existing ones), and completely forget that it costs about 48 cents a mile to drive (it’s not just the price of gas!).
And so we go buy SUVs because our roads are so bad, and we have to spend so much time in the car because we get stuck in so much traffic. They consume more oil so demand and price continue to grow. We build more roads which leave less room for houses which means we need to put houses further away whith then require more roads which invokves an infinite loop. The roads continue to suck up more tax dollars for maintenance, which we won’t want to pay so they’ll fall into worse shape and so we’ll need more car repairs and SUVs. Meanwhile buses and trains (if they even exist) will be able to serve fewer and fewer people meaning more and more cars on the road.
Which means even more time in the car.
Does that really sound like freedom to you?
I don’t have the answers, but I suspect figuring that out involves thinking more about the future, investing in the future, planning for sustainability, and planning for servicability.